Forums and Chat for Indonesia's English-speaking community
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#31901 - 26 Mar 06 08:59 AT/Indonesian coal a family affair
biznews Moderator Offline
Pujangga Besar

Registered: 24 Apr 08
Posts: 7508
Loc: Jakarta
From Asia Times

Mar 25, 2006

Indonesian coal a family affair
By Bill Guerin

JAKARTA - Indonesia's bountiful natural resources are generating massive corporate deals, a signal that one of the region's sickest post-Asian-financial-crisis economies is finally reviving. In the process, so too are some of the business families that ruled the roost under former president Suharto's New Order regime.

In one of Indonesia's largest ever corporate takeovers, Bumi Resources, the country's biggest coal exporter, was sold last week for US$3.2 billion to a group of investors led by Borneo Lumbung Energi, an affiliate of Jakarta-based investment bank Renaissance Capital, and the Marubeni Corp, Japan's fifth-largest trading company. The groups bought 95% of Kaltim Prima Coal (KPC) and 100% of Arutmin Indonesia and IndoCoal Resources Ltd at a whopping 54% premium on the company's current market value.

Marubeni is expected to cover up to 50% of the purchase and plans later to build a coal-fired power plant in Indonesia. The Japanese concern said it needs more coal to supplement supplies from its mines in Australia and Canada to meet the steep rise in demand for coal used at power plants at home and in China.

Bumi's decision to sell the lucrative mines comes at a time when surging demand in China and India have helped to buoy global commodity prices. Mining activities account for roughly 10% of Indonesia's gross domestic product, but the industry is still highly underdeveloped. At the same time, multinational resource companies are encountering a growing series of protests, attacks and nationalistic confrontations from various Indonesian interest groups.

The sale also represents the second-biggest divestment ever for an Indonesian company, topped only by last year's $5.2 billion sale of the country's second-largest cigarette producer, HM Sampoerna, to US tobacco giant Philip Morris International by the high-rolling Sampoerna family.

Bumi, affiliated to one of Indonesia's oldest and biggest conglomerates, Bakrie & Brothers Tbk, better known as the Bakrie Group, started life as Bumi Modern in 1973 and later became a major player in the hotel and tourism sector. The family company had close ties to Suharto, and like many Indonesian companies fell on hard times in the wake of the Asian financial crisis. In 1998, citing adverse economic conditions, the Bakrie family shifted its core business from domestic-oriented hotels to export-oriented oil, natural gas and mining.

The move paid off handsomely. Sources close to the deal said the Bakrie family and other members of the consortium put $750 million into the kitty, with the remaining $2.5 billion pledged from debt instruments arranged by Credit Suisse First Boston (CSFB). Last year Bumi successfully sold $600 million in dollar-denominated bonds, which were backed by cash flows generated at Arutmin Indonesia and Kaltim Prima Coal.

The deal has a notable political component, harking to the New Order days. Aburazil Bakrie, who until December served as senior economics minister and is now the coordinating minister for social welfare, is one of Indonesia's richest officials, with a declared personal wealth of $121.9 million. Last year he ran for the Golkar party leadership. Though he didn't win, his standing in Suharto's old party is strong, and Golkar is still popular in the regions, notably where most of the country's energy projects are.

Bakrie has been rumored to have links to Renaissance and its Recapital Asia subsidiary - though the family is on record denying any connection. Recapital Asia has been at the center of many recent blockbuster debt-restructuring deals. Edwin Soeryadjaya, son of the founder of Indonesia's national car company Astra, and Sandiaga S Uno, chairman of the Young Indonesian Entrepreneurs Association, jointly own Recapital Asia, which was previously known as Rifan Financindo Advisory.

Before establishing Renaissance, Samin Tan, Surjadinata Sumantri and Dessi Natalegawa were all partners at the Jakarta office of accounting firm Delloite Tohmatsu. To date the finance company's reputation in capital markets has been top-rate, and it has successfully secured international financing for restructuring several indebted Indonesian-owned enterprises. Its prowess in lobbying with the government's asset-management company, Perusahaan Pengelola Aset (PPA), and its current chairman Mohammad Syahrial is the envy of other Jakarta finance houses.

Market watchers say Renaissance can broker funds into deals that many lenders would not touch, allowing it to leverage big deals with little capital. With Renaissance up front, but not obviously linked, the Bakrie Group would not fear any stigma of recently being one of Indonesia's biggest indebted conglomerates and today one its most financially active, some insiders suggest.

Renaissance's Tan and Sumantri also jointly own Borneo Lumbung Energi, 75% and 25% respectively. Tan recently commented, "We will not sell Bumi again for the time being," a seeming admission that Renaissance has not only bought the two Bumi mines through Borneo Lumbung Energi, but is also calling managerial shots at Bumi.

Others behind Renaissance, like the founders themselves, had been leading executives in Chandra Asri, the first and only olefin (hydrocarbon) complex in Indonesia. Controversial from the outset, the $1.5 billion megaproject, awarded through the patronage networks of Suharto's New Order era, swallowed up vast amounts of money, suffered extraordinarily unfortunate timing, and highlighted the financial woes many Japanese trading companies suffered in their dealings with the then-ruling family's business associates.

"If Bakrie really is behind Renaissance, it would be a silent comeback for the family after losing control over Bank Nusa Nasional, one of the banks that merged [under government supervision] into Bank Danamon," said Yosef Ardi, a business editor at Bisnis Indonesia.

Back from the dead
In 2001, Bumi paid $140 million for its 80% stake in Arutmin from Australia's BHP Billiton. At the time, analysts were skeptical about the previously indebted company's ability to raise the funds needed to make the purchase. The deal was highly controversial given Bakrie's debt-restructuring exercise earlier that year, in which the company swapped $1.1 billion in debt for new equity, and was legally prohibited from making any new acquisitions. The deal went through nonetheless.

Bakrie's creditors then owned 95% of the diversified conglomerate, including a 20% stake in Arutmin. Two years later, Bumi bought the entire stake in KPC for $500 million, including assumed debt, from Anglo-American energy giant BP Plc and Anglo-Australian mining conglomerate Rio Tinto. The government estimated KPC's value at $822 million at the time.

Analysts noted that Bumi's debts at the time of the KPC acquisition were three times as high as its capital, with a debt-to-equity ratio of 3.2:1. In such a position, any banks following prudential banking principles would have been unlikely to offer the company new loans - hence there are many unanswered questions about the KPC deal.

The divestment process had been delayed for years, partly because of a dispute with the local administration. The deal was made at a time when the team, set up by Laksamana Sukardi, the state minister of state enterprises, was in the process of finalizing talks with the East Kalimantan administration. Sukardi had warned of "strict measures" against KPC if the company did not comply with Article 26 of the contract, which stated that KPC, like Arutmin, should only sell its shares to the Indonesian government, other Indonesian-owned institutions or Indonesian individuals.

By then, the two multinational resource giants had grown weary of the protracted squabble. Insiders say Bumi approached BP with an offer that persuaded the British energy giant to depart the local mining industry altogether. Rio Tinto, clearly averse to being left as the underdog in Indonesian hands, was quick to follow suit and agreed to the deal.

There was still unfinished business, however. Under the nationalistic 1982 Coal Cooperation Agreement, struck between the central government and individual companies, mines had to be 51% locally owned on the 10th anniversary of beginning operations. KPC was obligated to divest 51% of its ownership, with the first divestment scheduled for October 2003. Based on the purchase agreement between Sangata Holding, Kalimantan Coal and the Regency Government of East Kutai, 18.6% of KPC's shares were to be given to the regency, through Kutai Timur Energi, a district-owned company, leaving the to-be-divested stake at 32.4%.

Bumi offered this to a number of local companies through a tender. Little-known mining-service company Sitrade Nusaglobus won through a $399.98 million bid and in August established a new subsidiary, Sitrade Coal. The Bakrie Group at the time denied rumors that Sitrade was part of its holdings, but Bumi later purchased 99% of Sitrade Coal from Sitrade Nusa Globus for Rp7 billion ($700,000).

Revisiting the costs and the receipts from asset sales, Bumi's total outlay for the two mines was just short of $251 million, earning it an apparent net profit of just under $3 billion from the recent sale.

The company is expected this month to post 2005 earnings of about $237 million, and its shares rose 5.4% to a record Rp980 per share on news of the sale. Trading was later suspended by the Jakarta Stock Exchange pending further details of the transaction. (Trading resumed on Wednesday.) The current share price gives Bumi a market capitalization of Rp19 trillion ($2.08 billion), meaning that the sale price was an eye-popping 54% over the company's market value.

Why sell?
Last year Indonesia produced 155 million tons of coal, making it the world's second-biggest coal exporter after Australia. KPC and Arutmin are Indonesia's second- and fourth-largest coal producers respectively, and account for some 29% of national coal production. Combined, they generated $1.1 billion in net sales in 2005, with an operating income of $2.93 million. The mines have combined proven and probable marketable reserves of 959 million tons, according to energy analysts.

The Bumi mines hold contracts with several major Asian utility companies, but demand for coal will increase in Indonesia because of the planned construction of coal-fired power plants to meet spiking domestic electricity demand, which is growing by some 7% a year. The government has said it wants to speed up the construction of power plants fired by fuels other than oil amid high crude prices and fears of power shortages in Java, home to about 60% of Indonesia's 238 million people.

Bumi said in a statement that the sale, subject to approval from Bumi's shareholders, would allow the company "to realign its focus into the energy and natural resources sectors which management believes have greater long-term potential for Bumi".

Some of the money will be used to build plants that produce diesel from coal and crops such as oil palm. Another Bakrie family business, publicly listed Bakrie Sumatera Plantation, is planning to expand its oil-palm and rubber plantations in Sumatra and Kalimantan over the next three years to tap the growing demand for the commodities worldwide.

Nationally, Indonesia is also seeking to increase the use of other sources of energy such as natural gas and coal in the face of rising crude prices and declining domestic production. Within five days of the statement announcing the mines' sale, Bumi had publicly indicated its plans to build an 80,000-barrel-a-day coal-liquefaction factory in South Sumatra to help reduce petroleum use.

The company is also in discussions with South Africa's Sasol, the world's top producer of synthetic fuel, which converts coal or natural gas to liquid fuel without the generation of crude oil as an intermediary product. Eddie Soebari, Bumi's finance director, estimates that 48,000 tons of coal can be converted into 80,000 barrels of synthetic oil a day. To secure coal for the new project, Bumi plans to pay as much as $3 million for Sumatran company Pendopo Energi Batubara, which has estimated resources of more than 1.5 billion tons of low-energy coal.

Jeffrey Mulyono, head of Berau Coal, Indonesia's fifth-largest coal producer, and chairman of the Indonesian Mining Association, notes that if crude is above $26 a barrel, it makes economic sense to convert coal.

Shortly after the news about Sasol surfaced, Bumi officially confirmed its planned July merger with Energi Mega Persada (EMP), Indonesia's second-largest privately owned domestic oil-and-gas company with interests in eight exploration blocks and proven reserves of 319 million barrels. This will create Indonesia's biggest private energy company, with combined assets worth more than Rp21.1 trillion ($2.3 billion).

"We have opted for a share-swap deal ... to keep costs down," Bumi president Ari Saptari Hudaya said, adding that the company planned to use its capital to expand into new businesses.

Eye to eye visions
Bumi's plans are strikingly in line with the government's designs for the sector. Vice President Yusuf Kalla this week gave an upbeat assessment to potential international investors about future energy-oriented investment projects: "Please keep in mind that our country is so rich in resources. This will be an advantage for any industry in developing its business here. China and India have less resources compared to us."

Kalla also claimed that the government would make Indonesia's energy prices the lowest in the world by 2008 through the conversion of some 1,000 megawatts of oil-fueled power plants into gas, coal and geothermal plants. The combined capacity of state electricity utility power plants is currently 25,000MW, of which oil-based fuels generate 10,000MW.

The government projects are estimated to cost as much as $6 billion and the government has encouraged foreign investors to participate - though that invitation has not yet been put to the nationalistic test.

Foreign direct investment grew by 14% in 2005 to $12.1 billion, and the government hopes for another 15.2% increase this year. A draft investment bill is being debated in the House of Representatives, which, if passed, would turn the common 150-day or more process for finalizing investment permits into a one-stop, 30-day registration process.

Foreign investors would also have guarantees against any future nationalization - no small point given the recent concerted attempts by local protesters and opportunistic politicians to paint US mining giants Freeport McMoRan and Newmont as bogeymen in Indonesia. Kalla recently said the government should revise the profit-sharing contract with Freeport to give Indonesia a bigger slice of the revenues.

There have also been nationalistic rallies staged against the recent deal between state-owned oil company Pertamina and ExxonMobil Corp to jointly operate the country's largest untapped oilfield, known as Cepu.

But there could be bigger systemic troubles in the pipeline for foreign investors. Yogo Pratomo, director general for electricity and energy, revealed this week that the government is now reviewing existing regulations that would enable the government to scrap tender offers and directly appoint contractors. "It would take at least a year for the projects to get off the ground if we did it by tender."

Should this measure, which smacks of a return to Suharto's tendency to award contracts strictly to favored local businessmen, actually be implemented, Indonesian nationals would likely trump foreign suitors based on the quality of their connections rather than their business models or technical expertise. And, if that's the case, expect Bumi and the Bakrie family to get their fair share of the action.

<i>Bill Guerin, a Jakarta correspondent for Asia Times Online since 2000, has been in Indonesia for 20 years, mostly in journalism and editorial positions. He has been published by the BBC on East Timor and specializes in business/economic and political analysis related to Indonesia. He can be reached at
_________________________ Indonesian Business and Investment News Aggregator

#31902 - 26 Mar 06 09:49 Re: AT/Indonesian coal a family affair
Polar Bear Offline
Pujangga Besar

Registered: 23 Nov 05
Posts: 6177
I have always had this theory.

“A dictatorship isn’t so bad. You only get ripped off by one group of assholes”.

Here in Australia I have a corrupt local government who award planning applications upon payment of bribes, set incredible local rates, do dodgy business deals etc.

Then I have a State government who are even more corrupt, and are the highest taxing state in Australia.

Then I have a federal government who were bribing Saddam with money to keep fat wheat farmers in business.

I have a tax office who hound me for every cent they can get.

A police force who raise money with illegal speed cameras.

The list goes on.

I want to offer Suharto the job of king of Australia. At least I could see who was ripping me off, and at least Suharto was sometimes honest….

#31903 - 26 Mar 06 12:13 Re: AT/Indonesian coal a family affair
Ena Offline

Registered: 26 Nov 05
Posts: 765
Loc: Sydney
How old is he now anyway?
And what really happened to his wife all that time ago-was it one of the kids shot her or something? I forget the " behind the scene" theory now...

..take only what you need..

#31904 - 26 Mar 06 20:18 Re: AT/Indonesian coal a family affair
Polar Bear Offline
Pujangga Besar

Registered: 23 Nov 05
Posts: 6177
Im not looking for honesty, just for one dishonest lot. Right now everyone from the ATO to Sydney City council rip me off. I get garbage levies to pay fat stupid "environmental consultants" to advise on the size of garbage bins etc.

There is an economic "trickle down" theory that says if private individuals have money they spend it, allowing the wealth to trickle down to other members in society.

This doesn’t happen with government taxation, which squanders it on shit.

#31905 - 26 Mar 06 20:28 Re: AT/Indonesian coal a family affair
g00f13 Offline

Registered: 12 Nov 05
Posts: 739
Loc: earth
Best the devil you know.


Moderator:  biznews, NetCop